05:39:18Savamean free thought and Free Will it's it's it's it's like the ability to have that free thought and Free Will right fetus will have that ability yeah they
05:39:28Andrew Wilsonwill just as somebody like being in a coma correct they have that ability when they wake up they're already a person so then what you're actually col of cells yeah so if you if you make that statement though you are a collection
05:39:41Andrew Wilsonthere's an entailment so there's an entailment here the entailment is if you make the statement that the coma patient you value his life because he can have that experience then you would have to Value the life of the uh egg that's for
05:39:54Andrew WilsonI mean right away you would have to Value the life yeah the zygote because the potential for them to have the experience is the same yeah I think you know like not not necessarily
05:40:05Savabecause you know that person in the coma right they have already they're already a person you know capable of everything like that the collection of cells you know like like what you're what you're
05:40:17Savatalking about right is like it's basically like every time some like dude like nuts in a napkin you know that's that's that's not a
05:40:26Savannahlife a human being has it has to have it has to have go both gametes connect yeah you can't you have to have all 23 pairs of chromosomes you can't just have half
05:40:37Savannahof that that's that's a g not a zygote a zygote is a unque it's also potential the potential of life like you're talking it's not potential it has all eight characteristics of life the poti scientific fact you cannot argue against
05:40:50Caitlynthat as someone that stud medicine you should know that what are the eight characteristics of life I can't name them off the top of my head but I promise you it obtains all eight characteristics like reproduction
05:40:59Caitlynability to ability to reproduce yeah yeah ability to reproduce ability to move um ability to Breathe No No that's
05:41:10Savannahwrong like or like exch gases of some sort n okay I used to have them memorized I used to have them memorized but I promise you would obtain so this is like my subject you know what I'm
05:41:22Chasesaying okay two more anyways yeah I think it's murder and I I think it should be illegal and people should be arrested for consider also to make a point on
05:41:32Chasethis uh I saw in the news that um Peru re recently made abortion illegal and they're giving fetuses uh constitutional rights as a result of this or they're
05:41:45Chasethey're making it illegal because they've given fetus's constitutional rights I you know one of the weird things about living in America our Constitution and all of our rights that Andrew believes are
05:41:56Chasefake you know it's like America was was founded to secure life liberty in the pursuit of happiness for all Americans but why don't we why do we not secure the right to life for fetuses in America
05:42:09Chaseit doesn't make any sense like I I believe every unborn child has the right to life in America and that's what this nation was founded for should and I mean in our history as she was trying to say
05:42:19Savannahlike legislation somehow makes some kind of morality and it's like in history as humans we've taken away human rights from countless amount of people and we look back on that and we say what the heck were we thinking right and the same
05:42:31Chasething goes for a fetus embryo zygote whatever you want to call it it's just a different stage in human development it's a human life period yeah God willing like I pray that a day will come where we will look back on this era with
05:42:43Chaseover 60 million unborn children killed in the womb and we will be like what the hell why do you why do you want to control women's bodies I want to I want save the baby bodies bro I I do want to
05:42:56Savasay something though you brought up Peru right my actual my my best brought friend Peru my best friend a four years she's from there right and one thing you know like we've actually talked about so
05:43:08Savaone thing that's actually really dangerous over in Pur right is there's so many there's so many you know like uh um essays you know there's a lot of people a lot of women you know do you know what the actual number is no idea
05:43:21Savabut this is from her personal experience this is from what she's told me um you know what she's seen over there and I think one thing that we do have to look at is it's like even with taking away you know the right to abortion people
05:43:33Savaare still going to go and get them right people are still going to out of their way and then they're going to damage themselves and they're actually the third leading rate uh the third leading
05:43:44Savadeath for maternal deaths right is unsafe abortions in Peru um no every we just make homicide legal cuz it's still going to happen well yeah but I mean this is like allowing people the
05:43:57Savadecision you know nobody should have the decision to kill another innocent human being period so if a little so if a little I know this is like a a cliche type to topic but if a little girl is
05:44:09Savannahraped by a family member and is impregnated oh oh sorry sorry sorry do you know what percentage of abortions come from that in America no uterus no
05:44:20Brian Atlasopinion I mean well I have a uterus she does have a uterus I do have a uterus Andrew Wilson no uterus no
05:44:30Chaseopinion I hear what you're saying you know it's it sounds like this this is an argument that people commonly raise which is okay if you make abortion illegal then you will force women in those positions to get them by other
05:44:42Chasemeans which are often dangerous and and in danger the lives of the women that are getting them I totally understand that argument what I would also say to that is that women who legally get abortions also endanger their lives
05:44:54Chasethere are many women who have died from abortions in abortion clinics on top of that I think any woman that gets sa and becomes pregnant as a result of that that's a very sad thing but to her point
05:45:07ChaseI don't think just because one bad thing happened to you I don't think that justifies then murdering that unborn child I also am a firm believer in the stat it's just a clump of cells Chase
05:45:18Chaseyeah I'm I'm a firm believer it's actually ofs that's the thing that's super weird if I may add a couple more points I I'm a firm believer in the state making adoption services more
05:45:29Chaseaffordable for people right like I've raised this on previous episodes here in America for example it's insanely expensive to adopt a child and we print billions hundreds of billions trillions
05:45:41Chaseof dollars I don't know if it's trillions that we give in foreign aid to other countries but we here in America we give tons of money to all of these other countries I think a lot of that
05:45:50Savamoney should instead be put towards subsidizing the adoption somebody sanze this chair by the way one thing I want to ask is like what are what are your beliefs when it's in concern of the you
05:46:03Savaknow like threatening the life of the mother or the fetus has very very sever birth defects that upon birth but this a problem with this argument right it's like let's just for the sake of argument
05:46:15Andrew WilsonGrant it okay if it's going to threaten the mother's life fine if it's incest fine like whatever the qualifiers are the vast overwhelming majority of
05:46:25Andrew Wilsonabortions have nothing to do with those qualifiers so I feel like let's start with the vast overwhelming majority of them and then we can move on to kind of
05:46:36Chasewhatever the outliers are last I saw roughly 95% of abortions are what are called abortions of convenience 97 elective okay is that is that that's the statistic according to gut matcha
05:46:49ChaseInstitute that PL Parenthood uses for their statistics okay so if it's 97 let's break this down for a moment that means 97% of abortions are abortions that women are getting because it it is inconvenient for them to keep the child
05:47:02Chasethey didn't plan the pregnancy they don't want the kid maybe they feel they can't afford it so on and so forth which tells me women are making bad decisions with who they are let letting
05:47:13Chasecome inside of them and then they are killing their children as a result of it because they don't want to bear the consequences of their decisions here in America less than 1% of abortions are due to rape I have great compassion for
05:47:25Chasewomen that experience that and I can't even imagine how painful it would be sorry for using that word to be sa and then to feel like you have to get an abortion after the fact I can't imagine
05:47:35Chasehow painful that would be but to his point the overwhelming majority are women who are making terrible decisions with who they're allowing into their bodies and then they are just killing their children because they don't want
05:47:46Andrew Wilsonto bear the consequences of their actions yeah like let's just say for for a second that we just hypothetically Grant this to you we just agree we're like all of those outlier cases fine
05:47:58Andrew Wilsonthey should have been able to do it can you give us the justification for why all of the vast majority of the others shouldn't that's the question m
05:48:07Savaum so like I said you know like just my personal standpoint on it um is you know like that until that point of
05:48:17Andrew WilsonConsciousness is reached like which is there's it's only potential for Life 24 weeks 20 24 we not arguable when life
05:48:26Savahappens what happens in 24 weeks um I mean that's basically you know the start of like Consciousness that's that's the ability to you know kind of like feel
05:48:36Andrew Wilsonfeel like pain that's kind of like the start of you know the nervous this is again I I hate to I hate to ask this but I actually need to clarified yeah I still don't understand what you think
05:48:47Andrew Wilsonsentience or Consciousness is well she was just clarifying like the ability to feel pain and physical disorders that so for instance that doesn't make sense
05:48:57Andrew Wilsonbecause you can feel pain long for 24 weeks right long before 24 weeks so that can't be what you're referring to so what are you referring to as it's it's
05:49:07Savathe development into a person where I see that kind of breach right yeah what is the thing that is the breach like I said at 24 weeks it's the development towards Consciousness and it's the
05:49:19Savadevelopment towards Consciousness or withous I me around 24 weeks there's there's yeah but I'm asking what that quality is he's asking what would how do
05:49:29Andrew Wilsonyou define cons like so for if you said if you said to me it's when the foot the foot is developed I and be like what's the foot you say it's this part here what is sentience you keep on you say
05:49:41Savathat that's your value sentience Consciousness what is that it's it's like I said you know basically the ability for pain is basically you know like the start of like the nervous
05:49:53Savasystem I know we're going to agree separately on this but it's like just for me yeah but you can feel pain or you can have a nervous system before conscious I feel like you do have an outward kind of look upon life because
05:50:05Savayou know going like like I said into the medical field you go through you literally dissect human beings cabers you go through the entire system you see how people are built up you see how
05:50:16Savaeverything kind of starts right and it's like you know the throughout like there's like life and death right and there's
05:50:27Selenalike well H I'm sorry I'm not laughing at this at all please continue saying there's life and death you dissect cabers you can see the development of it there's life and
05:50:39Savannahdeath do you want to continue with it or did you lose your train of thought I got a degree in nursing and I can definitely assure you life begins at conception and I'm not saying that I am the person that
05:50:51Savannahdetermined that I'm just saying all scientific test textbooks and will tell you the same thing that a fetus obtains Oro obtains all eight characteristics of life if
05:51:03TTS/Donationsit's a life what kind of life is it it's a human life obviously a human being One Motorsports donated $200 as the baby is a result of sex is and the result of a man's seed why do we
05:51:15TTS/Donationsallow women to be the sole decisionmaking power to end that life the regret of the mother should not be the sole Factor another privilege as a woman that you should not have we should not allow women to be the sole
05:51:28Brian Atlasdecision-making power to end a baby's life exactly okay um it's getting late I think we should wrap up here pretty soon final thought from anybody before I wrap up I got some final thoughts I would
05:51:38Caitlynlike to pose the question what is life and then what is it's going to be different for everybody right the definition of life then we have everything from the trees to the human
05:51:49Savannahwhere do we put the you know on the value of everything what you do um sorry human life deserves human rights period and life is determined by biology and
05:52:01Savannahbiology tells us that a zygote has all eight characteristics of life therefore it is a life life a human being is two human gametes don't make anything else
05:52:12Savannahbesides a human yesod is a tree is a tree a seed though uh no it's a different develop no let me let me answer a question let me answer a question no it is a different development it's the same thing though
05:52:24Savannahit's the same thing right a seed grows into a tree right seeds grow into trees grow into trees but it is still the same species it is still the same tree that seed ended up being that tree correct end up being the tree correct that
05:52:37Savannahdoesn't mean that it it's a developmental stage same thing with saying an infant is it an adult and an adult isn't an elder it's the exact same
05:52:47Savaconcept do you do you believe do you believe um death is wrong no matter what like murder is wrong no matter what no absolutely I think there are sometimes justifications for death and like if
05:52:59Savannahsomebody's threatening me if somebody's threatening me right or if they're threatening you you have the right to defend yourself mhm but a fetus zygote embryo has done nothing to you they are innocent they are an innocent human
05:53:12Chasebeing hence why I keep saying innocent and is 97% of the time created by consensual decisions made by consens adults who don't want to deal with consequences of their actions elective
05:53:22Savannahabortions make up 97 so if I were to offer you legislation just curious that said you know what we're going to Outlaw
05:53:29Savannahall 97% of abortions as but we'll make exceptions for those uh for rate or R I
05:53:38Savannahdidn't finish it I didn't finish it for the RW yeah and um and in whatever and uh health of the mother would you agree
05:53:48Savato that um I think honestly between like me and you guys I think there's just a Divergence in belief no but I want to know like it's a yes or no question would you agree to that legislation oh sorry I explaining my
05:54:00Savapoint um anyway I think there's definitely like a Divergence and you know like what we kind of believe like is right you know I believe Mor starts at 24 weeks and we definitely do have it's a yes or no question just a
05:54:12Savannahagreement yeah I was getting to know but okay to know exactly so why do you bring it up what so why do you bring it up is trying to justify the other
05:54:22Savannah97% wait what what what are you talking about you're trying to use outliers like the RW and health of the mother right as
05:54:32Savannahoutliers to justify 97% of cases um if I offered you legislation if I offered you legislation would you accept it and the answer is no so why do you bring it up I
05:54:43Savaasked you guys a question concerning when you believe abortion is Right correct and I was getting your opinion on that never did I justify that I mean
05:54:54Chaseobviously I think abortion there definitely needs to be instances where it is legal no matter what anybody's opinion is right but do you okay so I
05:55:05Chaseunderstand that's your position but what she's asking is the other 97% that don't apply to the conditions that you're describing do you feel like that's morally wrong for those that 97%
05:55:17Savaof women to be getting abortions for decisions they chose to make um I mean personally you know like what I already explained you know how I see life or whatever like that so
05:55:29Savayou feel like if it's below that threshold it's not wrong um I mean like what somebody does is you know like their personal choice and as I said you know if those options like aren't available they're already going to try
05:55:42Savait you know like anyway and I think so let's just legal legal homicide well I mean War what about war what do you think about war different like I said if you have you have if
05:55:53Savannahsomeone is threatening you and if somebody is threatening you bodily harm you have the right to defend yourself I'm not saying all wars Justified though to clarify War but I mean a lot of the
05:56:03Savannahtime war is not justified that's the point so if it's not justified then it would be murder yeah exactly like I think we can actually agree on that one all right I got a couple closing
05:56:14Chasethoughts Jesus Christ is Lord amen he came to the Earth he lived died resurrected from the dead ascended to Heaven he's freaking coming back to at some point in time I don't know when that is seems like it's going to be soon
05:56:27Chaseuh he died for all of our sins including you guys I hope you guys come to know Jesus Christ and find Salvation in him because he offers you eternal life and uh what we have however many listeners that are going to listen to this believe
05:56:39Chasethat it's the truth read the book more than a carpenter by Josh McDow make the make the decision for yourself who you believe Jesus Christ is because everybody has to answer that question guys go to twitch.tv/ whatever drop us a follow and a prime sub on your way out
05:56:52Brian Atlastwitch.tv whatever Steve thank for the Prime oh I think I got you kiwi hoo hobo uh see around clay Aussie than for the prime or the tier one thank you guys thank you thank you okay um let me just
05:57:04Brian Atlasdouble check make sure we got all the chat I don't want to miss any um did you say any closing pods do you have any it's got to be quick I need to WAP like ASAP oh yeah you should definitely come
05:57:15Brian Atlassee me at The Crucible Andrew Wilson check out his channel guys check out his channel and okay guys so last call please hit the like button on your way out thank you for tuning in tonight you could have been anywhere in the
05:57:28Brian Atlasworld but you were here with me I appreciate that thank you to everyone who super chats donates and supports the show means the world thank you to grid one Sports Raven DT camh seberg LP modest jaama J Butler whiskey squirrel
05:57:41Brian Atlaseverybody else who super chatted tonight these are some of our uh top patrons in the past week and past month thank you guys thank you to the wonderful panel those of you who made it to the end any women who want to be on the show and you can make it to Santa Barbara DM at
05:57:52Brian Atlaswhatever on Instagram we will be live again Sunday 5:00 p.m. Pacific be sure to tune in I want to see 07 in the chat 07s in the chat we will see you next
05:58:03Brian Atlastime good night guys and good night we will see you